Retaining students? Not a good idea.
David Wees posted this topic to his blog, 21st Century Educator. He is arguing that grade retention is a bad idea. He tells a story about his first grade graduation, and how one of his friends was held back, and the look of disappointment on his face when they did not call his name. His point in telling this story was to show that it can be really painful for a child to go through that kind of experience. "The moments that we think kids will get over and forget about are actually the ones that kids remember most. If it would be a painful memorable experience for an adult, it's a painful memorable experience for a kid". To summarize my comment, I said that in certain cases I think that grade retention is okay. I said that it can have emotional effects on some children, but ultimately if the child did not successful complete that grade then they should have to repeat it,or at least get some form or tutoring. Moving on to a higher level, when you do not understand a lower level, is not a good idea.Understanding Nature
On this blog post David Wees is discussing how more children should have the opportunity to see nature and how amazing it can be. I agreed with him, I think it is really important that children get a chance to see and understand all of the beautiful places that are out there. If children got the chance to see a little more of nature than maybe they would have a greater respect for it. I suggested taking more nature focused field trips.
I agree with you on the retention of students. I can definitely see how it could be damaging to a student's self-esteem and morale, but at the same time, I think it would only do them injustice to pass them on to the next grade just to keep their spirits high. I think it's the responsibility of the teacher and parents throughout the school year to make sure that the student is on the right track and understanding that way in the end, retention isn't even an issue. Just my opinion...
ReplyDelete